PF Nav/HeadImage

PennFuture Facts :: brief, interesting looks at topical environmental issues PennFuture Facts :: brief, interesting looks at topical environmental issues
Showing posts with label coal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coal. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Video: Energy switching in six minutes: Part 1

Pop quiz! Ready?

Who is your electricity supplier?

      A) My local utility
      B) A renewable energy supplier in Pennsylvania 

If you answered B, give yourself a pat on the back. Simply by paying your bill every month, you are helping ensure that Pennsylvanians have clean, healthy air to breathe. Our lungs thank you. 

If you answered A, maybe now is the time to consider making the switch. 

Energy Switching Series,created by Nicole Catino for PennFuture
Much of Pennsylvania's electricity comes from coal-fired power plants, which spew pollution into our air. Unhealthy levels of air pollution in Pennsylvania contribute to asthma, COPD, lung disease and even cancer. 

While individuals and organizations (including PennFuture) work to ensure that our air is protected, you too can take a step to increase clean energy generation. You can choose to buy your electricity from renewable wind and solar sources, right here in Pennsylvania. Want to know more? This three-minute video outlines why energy switching matters.

Valessa Souter-Kline is western Pennsylvania outreach coordinator for PennFuture and is based in Pittsburgh. She tweets @ValessaSK.

Wednesday, June 25, 2014

Wall Street sounds alarm on climate

A bipartisan trio of Wall Street moneymen are sounding the alarm on climate change. Former New York City Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, former Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson and Tom Steyer, a former hedge fund manager, released a report this week detailing how climate change is expected to impact the American economy.

Their analysis: Between $66 billion and $106 billion in coastal property will likely be below sea level by 2050; labor productivity of outdoor workers could be reduced by 3 percent because extremely hot days will be far more frequent; and demand for electricity to power air conditioners will require the construction of more power plants that will cost electricity customers up to $12 billion per year.

The report calls for comprehensive public AND private sector response. But there are rays of hope.

Just this month, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced a historic standard to limit carbon pollution from existing power plants. This rule is likely to have the most impact on the oldest, dirtiest coal plants because they can't compete with relatively newer coal plants and other more economic alternatives. Because coal won't be able to compete, we'll likely see more natural gas production, especially here in Pennylvania.

But with more natural gas production, the threat of fugitive methane emissions rises. Methane is a highly potent greenhouse gas and, absent adequate controls, methane leaks across the natural gas supply chain could undo many of the potential environmental benefits natural gas can have over other fossil fuels like coal.

So the question is: Are we going to trading one climate killer (carbon dioxide) for another (methane)?

The good news: Methane leakage can be significantly and cost-effectively controlled with proper equipment and robust monitoring and repair. Colorado recently put in place the nation’s most comprehensive regulations to control air emissions from oil and gas operations, including the first direct state regulation of methane.

Next door, Ohio now also requires natural gas drillers to conduct quarterly inspections to find and fix leaks wherever they might occur.

Pennsylvania can, and should, be a national leader on methane. Other states have set the bar, and energy companies are meeting their tough new requirements. There’s no reason why it can’t happen here.

Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's Director of Outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.

Wednesday, June 11, 2014

New EPA clean power standard highlights need for methane regulations

We at PennFuture were thrilled about the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) announcement last week of the proposed standard to limit carbon pollution from existing power plants. As we discussed, this rule is likely to have the most impact on the oldest, dirtiest coal plants because they can't compete with relatively newer coal plants, natural gas plants and other more competitive electric power resources. 

But with more natural gas production on the way -- and the attendant methane leakage -- this Christian Science Monitor article raised an important question: Are we trading one climate killer (carbon dioxide) for another (methane)?
Since natural gas burns much cleaner than coal, producing about half as much carbon dioxide, making the switch from coal to gas can go a long way to achieving the rest of the remaining reductions, the administration seems to be thinking.
The big problem is that we don’t know what’s happening with methane emissions. Natural gas, which is essentially methane (CH4), may burn cleaner than coal, but what happens when it isn’t burned? As a greenhouse gas, methane emitted into the atmosphere is more than 20 times as potent as carbon dioxide over a 100-year period.
Natural gas production leaks methane along its entire supply chain – from drilling to storing, processing to distributing. 
.... 
Natural gas may still have a climate benefit over coal. And even if it doesn’t right now, methane leakage could turn out to be a very fixable problem, as engineers figure out how to plug the leaks in the supply chain. 
As the author points out, fugitive methane emissions are something we can address. But we must act now. Methane leakage can be significantly and cost-effectively controlled with proper equipment and robust monitoring and repair. Colorado recently put in place the nation’s most comprehensive regulations to control air emissions from oil and gas operations, including the first direct state regulation of methane. 

Next door, Ohio now also requires natural gas drillers to conduct quarterly inspections to find and fix leaks wherever they might occur. 

Pennsylvania can, and should, be a national leader on methane. Other states have set the bar, and energy companies are meeting their tough new requirements. There’s no reason why it can’t happen here. 

Andrew Sharp is Director of Outreach for PennFuture and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.

Wednesday, August 21, 2013

Corbett Is missing the boat, and we'll pay the price

Four former Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Administrators recently wrote an Op-Ed for the New York Times. If Governor Tom Corbett missed it, he needs to read it.

The subject was climate change. The four writers, William Ruckelshaus, Lee Thomas, William Reilly and Christine Todd Whitman, all headed the EPA under Republican presidents - Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan, George Bush, and George W. Bush, none of whom are light weights when it comes to conservative credentials. The Op-Ed makes several important points.

First, science does not support the claims of climate change deniers.
"There is no longer any credible scientific debate about the basic facts: Our world continues to warm, with the last decade the hottest in modern records, and the deep ocean is warming faster than the earth’s atmosphere. Sea levels are rising. Arctic Sea ice is melting years faster than projected."
Second, inaction on climate change has real costs, and we do not have time to wait.
"The costs of inaction are undeniable. The lines of scientific evidence grow only stronger and more numerous. And the window of time remaining to act is growing smaller: Delay could mean that warming becomes 'locked in.'"
Third, protection of the environment and public health has always been a conservative value.
"As administrators of the E.P.A ... we held fast to common-sense conservative principles — protecting the health of the American people, working with the best technology available and trusting in the innovation of American business and in the market to find the best solutions for the least cost.
That approach helped us tackle major environmental challenges to our nation and the world: The pollution of our rivers, dramatized when the Cuyahoga River in Cleveland caught fire in 1969; the hole in the ozone layer; and the devastation wrought by acid rain."
Fourth, conservatives should support President Obama's climate action plan to cut carbon emissions and invest in renewable resources.
"[P]resident Obama’s June climate action plan lays out achievable actions that would deliver real progress. He will use his executive powers to require reductions in the amount of carbon dioxide emitted by the nation’s power plants and spur increased investment in clean energy technology, which is inarguably the path we must follow to ensure a strong economy along with a livable climate."
Finally, action on climate change will promote and not harm the economy.
"We can have both a strong economy and a livable climate. All parties know that we need both. The rest of the discussion is either detail, which we can resolve, or purposeful delay, which we should not tolerate.       
[W]e must continue efforts to reduce the climate-altering pollutants that threaten our planet. The only uncertainty about our warming world is how bad the changes will get, and how soon. What is most clear is that there is no time to waste."
Regrettably, the administration in Harrisburg doesn't get it when it comes to climate change. Governor Corbett dodges questions about whether he believes in global warming, and seemingly lacks serious concern about the consequences of not taking action on climate change. Instead of working to cut carbon emissions and invest in clean energy technology, the Governor rejects any new investments in renewable power, all the while offering billions of dollars in subsidies to coal and gas interests.

In the words of four Republican EPA Administrators:
"[W]e must continue efforts to reduce the climate-altering pollutants that threaten our planet. The only uncertainty about our warming world is how bad the changes will get, and how soon. What is most clear is that there is no time to waste."
Should Governor Corbett continue to hide his head in the sand on climate change, Pennsylvanians will undoubtedly pay the price.

Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Fast Facts: Coal In the news from China to Pittsburgh

Free Coal, Shorter Life: A new study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences documents the disastrous results of China's policy of giving away free coal to residents of the Hua River area from 1950 to 1980. The pollution resulting from burning the coal contributed to shaving 5.5 years off of life expectancy there by increasing particulate matter in the air, which in turn led to increased heart and lung disease.

Divestiture: Kevin Begos reported this weekend for the AP that the United Church of Christ, a group of Protestant churches, had become the first U.S. religious body to vote to divest its pension funds and investments from fossil fuel companies because of climate change concerns. The Church of Christ claims 1.1 million members. The UCC General Synod 2013 also passed a resolution calling for an end to the devastating practice of mountain top mining.

Closure: First Energy Corp. announced that it will deactivate in October two coal-fired power plants in Pennsylvania - Mitchell Power Station in Washington County, and Hatfield's Ferry Power Station in Greene County. First Energy blamed the need to internalize the real cost of generating electricity from coal rather than being allowed to continually emit mercury and toxic air pollutants into the environment, and the low cost of electricity in the marketplace. According to the EPA, power plants are  the dominant emitters of mercury (50 percent), acid gases (over 75 percent) and a variety of toxic metals (20-60 percent) in the United States.

Review: On June 24, the Supreme Court announced that it will review a lower Court's decision that threw out EPA's Cross-State Air Pollution Rule. EPA adopted the rule in July of 2011, requiring 28 eastern states including Pennsylvania to reduce power plant emissions that contribute to pollution from ozone and fine particulate matter in other states. The Clean Air Act requires EPA and states to address the interstate transportation of air pollution that affects the ability of states downwind from attaining compliance with National Ambient Air Quality Standards.

Wednesday, June 26, 2013

CMU paper: Renewable subsidies should vary across the nation

I was driving on the Pennsylvania Turnpike near the town of Somerset recently when I was perplexed by a billboard that declared ominously, "Your tax dollars subsidize wind power."

Researchers from Carnegie Mellon University will publish a paper this week in the prestigious Proceedings of the National Academy of Science that argues for focusing renewable energy subsidies in those areas of the nation that will yield the greatest health and climate benefits - such as Ohio, Pennsylvania and West Virginia.

Those that argue against government subsidies for wind such as former US Rep. Phil Gramm, tend to use per watt figures to make their case that wind is not a good investment, instead of overall federal and state spending that shows government subsidies have historically favored black and not green energy sources.  The per watt figures that detractors use tend to ignore life cycle costs associated with subsidizing fossil fuels. For example, Gramm's figures do not account for the total cost to society of choosing coal over wind, such as the billions that will be needed to treat abandoned post-mining acid discharges, the lost recreational revenue because 5,000 miles of streams have been polluted by mining throughout the mid-Atlantic region, and the numerous health care costs of dirtying the air that our children breathe. The detractors also fail to account for the major economic benefits that would result from drastically reducing CO2 emissions by eliminating fossil fuel subsidies worldwide.

The researchers at Carnegie Mellon point out that wind and solar provide identifiable health benefits that should be considered and maximized by targeting government subsidies for renewables in areas of the country where clean energy would yield the greatest benefit to society.

This blog previously argued for a "health revenue" policy in Pennsylvania that recognizes the disparate effects of carbon-based fuels and renewables. That would allow a more descriptive billboard to read, "Your tax dollars subsidize less asthma attacks for your children and less heart attacks for your grandparents."

Thursday, May 16, 2013

Fast Facts

Does radon in shale gas pose a health problem?

State Impact (NPR) reports on a You Tube video that questions whether shale gas can increase cancer risks because it may contain radon.  The viral video was produced by a group that opposes a pipeline that will transport shale gas from Pennsylvania to New York. Michael Arthur from Penn State says there is not enough information but it is worth studying. PA DEP says that they "don't expect there to be much of an indoor air exposure issue" even though they haven't completed their year-long study that may generate facts to support that assumption.  The Marcellus Shale Coalition says that the group's claims "are unsupported by facts and science," all the while failing themselves to produce any studies or data on the group's concerns.

The question to us is which of these groups has access to the data that will answer the question, and why don't they know the answer?  The unknown is scary to the public, and yes, there are groups that will exploit that unknown.  But the burden here must fall on the industry and government.  The industry produces, transports and sells the gas.  As with any purveyor of goods, the industry should know what they are selling to the public and be able to answer these public health questions - not simply yell back at those groups like two kids in a playground.  And the government, which is now conducting a study more than eight years after it allowed production to proceed full-throttle, hampers its credibility when it makes assertions about public health issues without first having the facts in hand.  Let's get the facts and answer the question.

More good news for public health and the environment

The Harrisburg Patriot reports that NRG Energy will shutter two more coal-fired power plants - one in New Jersey and another in Pennsylvania. John Luciew, who wrote the post for the Patriot, adds plenty of commentary to the article - in his first sentence slamming "environmental groups" who he apparently sees cheering for the job losses from these closings while they "don't want fracking for natural gas either."

News flash to Luciew: all "environmental groups" are not built the same.  There are several that support the environmentally conscious development of gas so long as that production is part of a comprehensive plan that promotes energy efficiency, conservation and development of renewable energy. The principle of sustainability recognizes that we must meet the needs of the present while planning for and accommodating the needs of future generations.

And though Luciew emphasizes job losses from these plant closings, he does not report on the lives that have been cut short by the pollution spewed out of these aging plants over the years. The true cost of society relying on coal for energy - from acid mine drainage and mercury in our streams, to heart attacks and climate change - has never been fully internalized by the industry. And worse, Pennsylvania continues to subsidize the industry by billions of dollars per year - something our governor refuses to do for alternative energy that would cause much less harm to the public and our environment.

And speaking of which ...

Governor Corbett announced that he recently awarded a whopping $32,880 in energy-efficiency grants to four small businesses "because investment in small business is a cornerstone to economic growth." Hey, it's not $1.65 billion that he's willing to pay for a cracker - apparently a bit larger of a cornerstone - but it's worth what we used to call a "finger nail clap."  So this one's for you, governor ...


Wednesday, April 10, 2013

Natural Gas Poised to Push King Coal Off the Throne

As blogged by Brad Plumer at the Washington Post, a peer reviewed study by Duke indicates that natural gas will continue to push out dirty coal as the least cost power generation option so long as average natural gas to coal price remains below 1.8 (it was 1.42 in February 2012). The study indicates that if new air emission limitations are enforced against coal power plants, natural gas plants will remain competitive with coal plants up to a ratio of 4.3. In other words, as coal plants are required to absorb the real cost of harm that they impose on the public and environment, cleaner burning natural gas will be competitive even when the average cost of gas is four times that of dirty coal.