Over the past year, the chatter on methane pollution from oil and gas operations has gotten much louder—and that's a good thing. This has been helped along by the fact that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) proposed rules in August 2015 to cut methane pollution from new and modified sources in the oil and gas industry. Going a step further, Gov. Tom Wolf proposed a four-point plan in January 2016 to curb methane pollution from new and existing sources of oil and gas operations in Pennsylvania. Last month, President Obama and Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau pledged to work on rules for existing sources of oil and gas methane pollution that would address emissions across the U.S. and Canada.
It's the latter proposals to cut existing sources of oil and gas methane pollution that have caused much consternation among oil and gas producers. These companies, and their lobbyists, are quick to offer sound bites suggesting that they've got this, they are addressing existing sources of pollution voluntarily as it's in their best interest, and that there's no need for what they view as unnecessary and duplicative standards. The short answers, from where we sit, are no, no and no.
Existing sources of oil and gas operations, or the hundreds of thousands of wells, tanks, and compressor stations across the U.S., routinely vent, flare and leak methane. Methane, or CH4, is the primary constituent of natural gas and is a potent greenhouse gas, 86 times more so than carbon dioxide in the first 20 years after its release into the atmosphere. This airborne pollution is a public health problem, a waste of our natural resources, and a climate disaster in the making.
When oil and gas producers refer to methane pollution and say they've got this, they're wrong. Methane pollution from existing sources—the bulk of the problem—continue to increase as both Pennsylvania and EPA inventories indicate. Where we have seen some marked declines is in the category of green well completions, or the process of completing a well and readying it for production. It's worth noting that green completions are the one regulated category of methane emissions. Two words: Rules work.
As to voluntary compliance, that's pretty much another fallacy. The EPA's Natural Gas STAR program, which promotes voluntary efforts to rein in oil and gas pollution, struggles with woefully low buy-in from the industry. While Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) Secretary John Quigley has singled out Southwestern, Shell, Chevron and CONSOL as large producers that work to cut methane pollution, he also acknowledges that the bulk of small-mid size producers are nowhere near curbing emissions on a voluntary basis. Further, Quigley has stated that methane emission figures in the state are "unrealistically low" because leaks are so common and rarely measured.
Lastly, the suggestion that proposed methane rules for existing sources in Pennsylvania would be unnecessary and duplicative is absurd. Unnecessary? See the two previous paragraphs. Duplicative? Impossible, as Pennsylvania currently has no comprehensive regulatory framework for methane pollution from oil and gas operations. Colorado does, Pennsylvania is working on it, and California recently proposed its own suite of methane rules. We applaud Sec. Quigley's continued call for "best-in-the-nation" standards on methane pollution in PA.
Existing sources of methane pollution are a clear and present danger and must be addressed. The Wolf administration is on its way to doing just that, and 70 percent of Pennsylvanians in a recent poll support the effort. The proposed rules are laudable, and we thank the governor for his bold leadership.
In the weeks and months ahead, PennFuture will provide ample opportunity for citizens of the commonwealth to show their support for rules that cover existing sources of methane pollution. It's time to rein in this harmful pollution and protect our communities. We stand ready to help.
Elaine Labalme is strategic campaigns director for PennFuture and is based in Pittsburgh.
Showing posts with label EPA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EPA. Show all posts
Wednesday, April 13, 2016
Thursday, November 12, 2015
All across the U.S., the talk is about "existing sources"
I had the pleasure, and privilege, of participating in a national methane fly-in on November 4-6 in Washington, D.C. Lest you think we flew methane-spewing drones over our nation's capital, this was actually a collection of 35 advocates from 10 states who met to discuss the issue of harmful methane pollution from the oil and gas sector. We also met with our elected leaders to urge them to support the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) recently proposed rule to cut methane emissions from new and modified sources in the oil and gas sector including oil and gas wells and compressor stations.
And there's the rub. While we applaud the EPA for taking this important first step -- and it's certainly a step in the right direction -- the bulk of the methane pollution problem is from existing sources of emissions, or oil and gas wells that are here today, not waiting to be drilled tomorrow. By 2018, it is expected that 90 percent of methane pollution in the oil and gas sector will come from existing sources of emissions. In Pennsylvania, the second-largest natural gas producing state in the nation, that numbers thousands upon thousands of wells.
It was validating to hear that environmental advocates from as far away as New Mexico, Montana and North Dakota are just as concerned as we are in Pennsylvania around existing sources of methane pollution. These harmful emissions contribute to negative public health outcomes such as asthma attacks in children and lung and heart disease in seniors and those in under-served communities; are a wasted natural resource in that the $1 billion of methane emissions in 2013 could have heated five million U.S. homes and returned revenue to local communities; and exacerbate climate change as methane, the primary component of natural gas, is a potent greenhouse gas with 86 times the warming potential of carbon dioxide in the first 20 years after its release into the atmosphere.
Forget the triple bottom line -- methane pollution is a disastrous triad for public health, the economy and the environment.
Here in Pennsylvania, we continue to call on Gov. Tom Wolf to launch a rulemaking for the direct regulation of methane emissions in Pennsylvania from new, modified and existing sources in the oil and gas sector.
In Washington, D.C. last week, our 10-state group of advocates -- which included representatives from labor, faith, parent and environmental groups along with passionate members of the Native American community -- had the opportunity to meet with representatives of the EPA's Bureau of Air Quality and urge the agency to expand its proposed methane rule to cover existing sources as well.
This is a fight we must win, and I was honored to stand alongside like-minded individuals in our nation's capital who were unafraid to sound the call for comprehensive, essential methane rules to protect our citizens and communities.
Elaine Labalme is strategic campaigns director for PennFuture and is based in Pittsburgh. She tweets @NewGirlInTown.
And there's the rub. While we applaud the EPA for taking this important first step -- and it's certainly a step in the right direction -- the bulk of the methane pollution problem is from existing sources of emissions, or oil and gas wells that are here today, not waiting to be drilled tomorrow. By 2018, it is expected that 90 percent of methane pollution in the oil and gas sector will come from existing sources of emissions. In Pennsylvania, the second-largest natural gas producing state in the nation, that numbers thousands upon thousands of wells.
It was validating to hear that environmental advocates from as far away as New Mexico, Montana and North Dakota are just as concerned as we are in Pennsylvania around existing sources of methane pollution. These harmful emissions contribute to negative public health outcomes such as asthma attacks in children and lung and heart disease in seniors and those in under-served communities; are a wasted natural resource in that the $1 billion of methane emissions in 2013 could have heated five million U.S. homes and returned revenue to local communities; and exacerbate climate change as methane, the primary component of natural gas, is a potent greenhouse gas with 86 times the warming potential of carbon dioxide in the first 20 years after its release into the atmosphere.
Forget the triple bottom line -- methane pollution is a disastrous triad for public health, the economy and the environment.
Here in Pennsylvania, we continue to call on Gov. Tom Wolf to launch a rulemaking for the direct regulation of methane emissions in Pennsylvania from new, modified and existing sources in the oil and gas sector.
In Washington, D.C. last week, our 10-state group of advocates -- which included representatives from labor, faith, parent and environmental groups along with passionate members of the Native American community -- had the opportunity to meet with representatives of the EPA's Bureau of Air Quality and urge the agency to expand its proposed methane rule to cover existing sources as well.
This is a fight we must win, and I was honored to stand alongside like-minded individuals in our nation's capital who were unafraid to sound the call for comprehensive, essential methane rules to protect our citizens and communities.
Elaine Labalme is strategic campaigns director for PennFuture and is based in Pittsburgh. She tweets @NewGirlInTown.
Wednesday, August 5, 2015
Does a coal-to-gas switch = bad to worse?
On August 3, 2015, President Obama announced the final rule for the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Clean Power Plan, which aims to cut carbon pollution from power plants by 32 percent by 2030.
The good news in Pennsylvania is that we're already roughly halfway to meeting that goal. A Statewide Implementation Plan will be crafted over the next year that will allow us to meet the full goal utilizing "building blocks," which include adding more renewable energy to Pennsylvania's electric generation mix and accelerating energy efficiency, increasing efficiency at coal-fired power plants, and making a switch in electric generation from coal to natural gas.
Okay, not so fast on that last one as a switch from coal to natural gas warrants a close look. Carbon pollution from coal-fired power plants is indeed a huge problem as C02 is a greenhouse gas that will warm our planet, and remain in the atmosphere, for a very long time. Centuries. Natural gas, on the other hand, is a cleaner burning fuel whose current low prices makes it an (apparent) logical choice for a coal-to-gas switch.
However, natural gas operations bring the very real issue of methane emissions as a by-product of drilling operations. Methane or CH4, the primary component of natural gas, is a far more potent greenhouse gas than coal, up to 84 times more so in the first 20 years after its release into the atmosphere. While it remains in the atmosphere for a shorter time than carbon, its planetary warming wreaks a tremendous amount of havoc in the meantime.
If we are to truly combat climate change, we must address both carbon and methane emissions. Simply trading one for the other accomplishes little.
Where we need to focus our energy in the battle against climate change is on renewable energy and energy efficiency. These cleaner measures will create good-paying jobs and save consumers money on their electric bills. Pennsylvania currently boasts 57,000 jobs in the clean energy sector and is poised for many more. Studies show that aggressive energy efficiency measures could drive down electricity bills by nearly 10 percent by 2030.
As the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) readies its response to the Clean Power Plan, it must also roll out strong standards that address methane emissions from both new and existing sources of natural gas operations. We cannot trade one problem for another since that will only make a bad situation worse.
Elaine Labalme is strategic campaigns director for PennFuture and is based in Pittsburgh. She tweets @NewGirlInTown.
The good news in Pennsylvania is that we're already roughly halfway to meeting that goal. A Statewide Implementation Plan will be crafted over the next year that will allow us to meet the full goal utilizing "building blocks," which include adding more renewable energy to Pennsylvania's electric generation mix and accelerating energy efficiency, increasing efficiency at coal-fired power plants, and making a switch in electric generation from coal to natural gas.
Okay, not so fast on that last one as a switch from coal to natural gas warrants a close look. Carbon pollution from coal-fired power plants is indeed a huge problem as C02 is a greenhouse gas that will warm our planet, and remain in the atmosphere, for a very long time. Centuries. Natural gas, on the other hand, is a cleaner burning fuel whose current low prices makes it an (apparent) logical choice for a coal-to-gas switch.
However, natural gas operations bring the very real issue of methane emissions as a by-product of drilling operations. Methane or CH4, the primary component of natural gas, is a far more potent greenhouse gas than coal, up to 84 times more so in the first 20 years after its release into the atmosphere. While it remains in the atmosphere for a shorter time than carbon, its planetary warming wreaks a tremendous amount of havoc in the meantime.
![]() |
| Photo credit: WCN 24/7 via Flickr Creative Commons |
If we are to truly combat climate change, we must address both carbon and methane emissions. Simply trading one for the other accomplishes little.
Where we need to focus our energy in the battle against climate change is on renewable energy and energy efficiency. These cleaner measures will create good-paying jobs and save consumers money on their electric bills. Pennsylvania currently boasts 57,000 jobs in the clean energy sector and is poised for many more. Studies show that aggressive energy efficiency measures could drive down electricity bills by nearly 10 percent by 2030.
As the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) readies its response to the Clean Power Plan, it must also roll out strong standards that address methane emissions from both new and existing sources of natural gas operations. We cannot trade one problem for another since that will only make a bad situation worse.
Elaine Labalme is strategic campaigns director for PennFuture and is based in Pittsburgh. She tweets @NewGirlInTown.
Wednesday, July 29, 2015
Why voluntary standards alone will not reduce harmful methane emissions
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) recently expanded its Natural Gas STAR Methane Challenge Program, a voluntary framework for the reduction of methane emissions from the oil and gas sector. While all efforts to reduce the emissions of methane, a potent greenhouse gas, are welcome, it is clear that voluntary standards alone don't work as less than one percent of oil and gas producers are currently participating in the Natural Gas STAR program.
Methane has a global warming potential 84 times greater than carbon in the first 20 years after its release into the atmosphere. Along with other co-pollutants, it leads to the formation of ground-level ozone, or smog, a known contributor to asthma attacks and lung and heart disease. These twin climate killers are putting both public health and our environment at risk.
The technology exists today to capture and control methane emissions for pennies per thousand cubic feet of gas. What Pennsylvania needs are strong rules to curb methane emissions from both new and existing sources that include a robust leak detection and repair program. While programs that help achieve that goal are welcome, it's clear that voluntary standards alone won't do the trick.
Read more on the need for strong, enforceable standards on methane emissions from the National Wildlife Federation and the Environmental Defense Fund.
Elaine Labalme is Strategic Campaigns Director for PennFuture and is based in Pittsburgh. She tweets @NewGirlInTown.
Methane has a global warming potential 84 times greater than carbon in the first 20 years after its release into the atmosphere. Along with other co-pollutants, it leads to the formation of ground-level ozone, or smog, a known contributor to asthma attacks and lung and heart disease. These twin climate killers are putting both public health and our environment at risk.
![]() |
| Photo credit: WCN 24/7 via Flickr Creative Commons |
The technology exists today to capture and control methane emissions for pennies per thousand cubic feet of gas. What Pennsylvania needs are strong rules to curb methane emissions from both new and existing sources that include a robust leak detection and repair program. While programs that help achieve that goal are welcome, it's clear that voluntary standards alone won't do the trick.
Read more on the need for strong, enforceable standards on methane emissions from the National Wildlife Federation and the Environmental Defense Fund.
Elaine Labalme is Strategic Campaigns Director for PennFuture and is based in Pittsburgh. She tweets @NewGirlInTown.
Wednesday, January 28, 2015
Industry cherry-picks data to downplay methane problem
Our friends at the Allegheny Front provide an excellent "cheat sheet" on President Obama's new methane rules. Not surprisingly, the oil and gas industry opposes the regulations and says self-policing is the answer. (Stop me if you've heard that one before.)
To bolster their position, industry claims that methane emissions are down:
Although Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program data shows the industry’s total methane emissions fell 12 percent between 2011 and 2013, emissions from key activities not currently covered by federal standards went up substantially.
Reported declines after 2009 also completely ignore oil well emissions, which account for a substantial share of the sector’s total methane footprint.
Even those numbers don’t paint the whole picture.
Two other recent national studies suggest EPA’s overall estimates of methane emissions from the oil and gas industry are too low by half based on actual methane emissions measured by scientists.
Taken together, there is a body of evidence that shows that methane emissions are a huge problem that needs to be addressed -- which is why EPA's new rules on methane are a solid first step. But much more remains to be done. The good news is that low-cost, high-impact regulations provide an opportunity to help fight climate change, improve air and public health -- and prevent waste of product. The time for action is now.
Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets @RexBainbridge.
To bolster their position, industry claims that methane emissions are down:
"Industry points to the EPA’s own numbers, which show that, even as oil and gas production has surged, methane emissions have declined by 17 percent."This is a point that has been made repeatedly by industry types so it's helpful to unpack it -- and set the record straight.
Although Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program data shows the industry’s total methane emissions fell 12 percent between 2011 and 2013, emissions from key activities not currently covered by federal standards went up substantially.
Reported declines after 2009 also completely ignore oil well emissions, which account for a substantial share of the sector’s total methane footprint.
Even those numbers don’t paint the whole picture.
Two other recent national studies suggest EPA’s overall estimates of methane emissions from the oil and gas industry are too low by half based on actual methane emissions measured by scientists.
Taken together, there is a body of evidence that shows that methane emissions are a huge problem that needs to be addressed -- which is why EPA's new rules on methane are a solid first step. But much more remains to be done. The good news is that low-cost, high-impact regulations provide an opportunity to help fight climate change, improve air and public health -- and prevent waste of product. The time for action is now.
Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets @RexBainbridge.
Wednesday, October 15, 2014
Legislative #FAIL: PA House and Senate side with special interests on two bad bills
Late Wednesday, the Pennsylvania legislature passed two bad bills that will harm the water and air of Pennsylvanians. Both HB 1565, the Subdivision Flooding Bill, and HB 2354, the Stall on Carbon Bill, kowtow to powerful special interests as they dismiss the need for clean air and water for all Pennsylvanians.
The Stall on Carbon Bill allows either chamber of the General Assembly to block and delay Pennsylvania from submitting its carbon rule compliance plan to the Environmental Protection Agency, raising the likelihood that Pennsylvania cedes control of its compliance program to the federal government. By creating three different entities (House, Senate and Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection) with authority over the compliance plan, negotiation efforts by affected businesses and stakeholders will be confounded.
Further, the bill raises serious constitutional issues related to separation of powers. Rather than craft a feasible system to enhance legislative oversight of Pennsylvania’s carbon rule compliance, the bill is rife with stalling tactics as it creates layers of legal and procedural complications to the detriment of the people and businesses of the state. The Stall on Carbon Bill is an American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) initiative championed by Pennsylvania’s coal industry.
The Subdivision Flooding Bill ignores the twin issues of stormwater runoff and flooding as it caters to the state's powerful builders lobby. Pennsylvania citizens and communities have paid dearly in safety, life and property as a result of the consequences of flooding and stormwater. Part of the reason is the loss of riparian buffers in headwater and other streams that hold and slowly release rain and runoff. Passage of the bill now jeopardizes the riparian buffers along Exceptional Value and High Quality streams that not only reduce flooding and stormwater runoff, but markedly improve water quality, decrease pollution, protect drinking water, and improve habitat for fish and other wildlife.
Passage of these bills at the eleventh hour only serves to appease deep-pocketed interests and large campaign contributors. These bills can in no way be seen as helping to protect public health and safety. Rather, they do exactly the opposite.
Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.
The Stall on Carbon Bill allows either chamber of the General Assembly to block and delay Pennsylvania from submitting its carbon rule compliance plan to the Environmental Protection Agency, raising the likelihood that Pennsylvania cedes control of its compliance program to the federal government. By creating three different entities (House, Senate and Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection) with authority over the compliance plan, negotiation efforts by affected businesses and stakeholders will be confounded.
Further, the bill raises serious constitutional issues related to separation of powers. Rather than craft a feasible system to enhance legislative oversight of Pennsylvania’s carbon rule compliance, the bill is rife with stalling tactics as it creates layers of legal and procedural complications to the detriment of the people and businesses of the state. The Stall on Carbon Bill is an American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) initiative championed by Pennsylvania’s coal industry.
The Subdivision Flooding Bill ignores the twin issues of stormwater runoff and flooding as it caters to the state's powerful builders lobby. Pennsylvania citizens and communities have paid dearly in safety, life and property as a result of the consequences of flooding and stormwater. Part of the reason is the loss of riparian buffers in headwater and other streams that hold and slowly release rain and runoff. Passage of the bill now jeopardizes the riparian buffers along Exceptional Value and High Quality streams that not only reduce flooding and stormwater runoff, but markedly improve water quality, decrease pollution, protect drinking water, and improve habitat for fish and other wildlife.
Passage of these bills at the eleventh hour only serves to appease deep-pocketed interests and large campaign contributors. These bills can in no way be seen as helping to protect public health and safety. Rather, they do exactly the opposite.
Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.
Tuesday, September 23, 2014
This Thursday: PennFuture hosts rally and press conference at State Capitol
A broad coalition from the business, health care and faith communities along with moms and others fighting for clean air will speak to the importance of the EPA Clean Power Plan on Thursday at the State Capitol in Harrisburg. Speakers will testify later in the day at a DEP listening session on the Plan.
As Pennsylvania's Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) admitted its initial strategy for compliance with the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Clean Power Plan would be rejected by the Agency, Gov. Tom Corbett asked President Obama to rescind the rule and, most recently, questioned the legality of the rule in a letter to the president signed by 14 other governors.
Rather than researching a wide range of options for how Pennsylvania can comply with this rule, and identifying the most cost-effective plan for the residents and businesses of the state, Gov. Corbett and DEP are choosing to stonewall and laying out plans that deny the merits of the rule. State-level leadership comes with the responsibility to act in the best interests of the people of Pennsylvania.
Carbon pollution fuels climate change, triggers more asthma attacks and respiratory disease, worsens air quality, and contributes to more frequent, destructive, costly and deadly extreme weather events. The Clean Power Plan will prevent up to 150,000 asthma attacks and 6,600 premature deaths annually by 2030 as it promotes a clean energy economy.
WHAT: Press conference and rally calling on DEP and Corbett administration to stop stonewalling EPA carbon pollution standards for power plants
WHEN: Thursday, September 25, at 10 a.m.
WHERE: Capitol Rotunda, N. Third and State Streets, Harrisburg, Pa.
WHO: Larry Schweiger, immediate past president, National Wildlife Federation
Gretchen Dahlkemper-Alfonso, Moms Clean Air Force
Jamie Gauthier, Sustainable Business Network
Sister Mary Elizabeth Clark, Sisters of St. Joseph Earth Center
Sharon Pillar, SmartPower
Cherie Eichholz, Physicians for Social Responsibility
Matt Walker, Clean Air Council
Rob Altenburg, PennFuture
Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.
As Pennsylvania's Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) admitted its initial strategy for compliance with the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Clean Power Plan would be rejected by the Agency, Gov. Tom Corbett asked President Obama to rescind the rule and, most recently, questioned the legality of the rule in a letter to the president signed by 14 other governors.
Rather than researching a wide range of options for how Pennsylvania can comply with this rule, and identifying the most cost-effective plan for the residents and businesses of the state, Gov. Corbett and DEP are choosing to stonewall and laying out plans that deny the merits of the rule. State-level leadership comes with the responsibility to act in the best interests of the people of Pennsylvania.
Carbon pollution fuels climate change, triggers more asthma attacks and respiratory disease, worsens air quality, and contributes to more frequent, destructive, costly and deadly extreme weather events. The Clean Power Plan will prevent up to 150,000 asthma attacks and 6,600 premature deaths annually by 2030 as it promotes a clean energy economy.
*********
WHAT: Press conference and rally calling on DEP and Corbett administration to stop stonewalling EPA carbon pollution standards for power plants
WHEN: Thursday, September 25, at 10 a.m.
WHERE: Capitol Rotunda, N. Third and State Streets, Harrisburg, Pa.
WHO: Larry Schweiger, immediate past president, National Wildlife Federation
Gretchen Dahlkemper-Alfonso, Moms Clean Air Force
Jamie Gauthier, Sustainable Business Network
Sister Mary Elizabeth Clark, Sisters of St. Joseph Earth Center
Sharon Pillar, SmartPower
Cherie Eichholz, Physicians for Social Responsibility
Matt Walker, Clean Air Council
Rob Altenburg, PennFuture
Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.
Wednesday, September 3, 2014
Needed: Both state and federal methane standards
From Bloomberg:
The threat of methane emissions from natural gas drilling has been coming into clearer focus this year, and there is palpable momentum for action. Some states aren't waiting for the feds.The Environmental Protection Agency is considering rules that would force oil and gas producers to cut methane emissions, its chief said, stepping up efforts to curb the most potent greenhouse gas linked to climate change.Gina McCarthy, the EPA administrator, told investors at a New York forum today the agency will decide this year whether to issue regulations mandating emission cuts, or to rely only on voluntary steps.“We are looking at what are the most cost-effective regulatory and-or voluntary efforts that can take a chunk out of methane in the system,” McCarthy said. “It’s not just for climate, but for air quality” reasons, she said.Methane is 21 times more potent than carbon dioxide, and climate advocates have said that without curbs on emissions from the oil and gas industry, President Barack Obama will fall short of his goal to cut climate-change emissions. The administration’s plan to cut methane, issued in March, said the EPA would decide whether to regulate the industry. Rules, if issued, would take effect in 2016, the government said.
- In February, Colorado enacted a comprehensive suite of methane regulations for oil and gas operators – including an LDAR (leak detection and repair) program that requires the bulk of operators to perform quarterly inspections and even requires monthly inspections at the largest well sites.
- Right next door, Ohio recently revised its general permit that requires drillers of unconventional oil and gas wells to conduct quarterly LDAR inspections – in contrast to the once-a-year requirement for Pennsylvania well operators to qualify under Exemption 38.
- Last fall, Wyoming also implemented a new presumptive BACT requirement that includes quarterly inspections and repairs.
So, what is Pennsylvania doing? Not nearly enough. Pennsylvania's methane rules fall far short of what other states are doing -- and what is needed. The potential for federal methane rules is a big step in the right direction. This strategy has the potential to deliver the federal regulatory oversight that is needed to complement state efforts and make sure that all of the oil and gas industry meets basic, common-sense standards to deploy readily available technologies. But federal rules don't replace the need for state action. As the fastest growing natural gas producer in the country -- and a state that emits nearly a full percent of the world's greenhouses gases -- Pennsylvania can't afford to wait.
Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets @RexBainbridge.
Labels:
carbon dioxide,
climate,
emissions,
EPA,
Gina McCarthy,
methane,
natural gas
Wednesday, June 25, 2014
Get on the bus! A huge day for climate action coming up
July 31 is shaping up to be a huge day for climate action in Pennsylvania. And not just because it's likely to be hot. Pittsburgh has been chosen as one of only four cities in the nation to host Environmental Protection Agency hearings on the newly-proposed standard to limit industrial carbon pollution from existing coal-fired power plants.
Pittsburgh EPA Hearing
Thursday, July 31
9:00 a.m. — 8:00 p.m.
William S. Moorhead Federal Building
Room 1310
1000 Liberty Avenue
This hearing will give all Pennsylvanians (and even our neighbors in surrounding states) a chance to shine -- and make their voices heard in support of EPA's strong rules on carbon pollution. There will also be noon rally near the Federal building to show support (stay tuned for more details).
What you need to do: Sign up to testify. Everyone is welcome — whether you're an individual, on staff or a volunteer for an environmental community group, a business owner, a teenager concerned about the future, a faith leader — anyone can and should testify. No expertise required — just passion about climate change.
We're providing a FREE bus from Harrisburg to Pittsburgh for folks who want to attend the rally and show their support. More buses are being scheduled from State College and Erie, and we hope to have that info posted soon.
Eager to hear more? Email <quinn at pennfuture dot org.>
Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's Director of Outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.
Pittsburgh EPA Hearing
Thursday, July 31
9:00 a.m. — 8:00 p.m.
William S. Moorhead Federal Building
Room 1310
1000 Liberty Avenue
This hearing will give all Pennsylvanians (and even our neighbors in surrounding states) a chance to shine -- and make their voices heard in support of EPA's strong rules on carbon pollution. There will also be noon rally near the Federal building to show support (stay tuned for more details).
What you need to do: Sign up to testify. Everyone is welcome — whether you're an individual, on staff or a volunteer for an environmental community group, a business owner, a teenager concerned about the future, a faith leader — anyone can and should testify. No expertise required — just passion about climate change.
We're providing a FREE bus from Harrisburg to Pittsburgh for folks who want to attend the rally and show their support. More buses are being scheduled from State College and Erie, and we hope to have that info posted soon.
Eager to hear more? Email <quinn at pennfuture dot org.>
Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's Director of Outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.
Labels:
climate action,
EPA,
hearing,
Pittsburgh
Wednesday, June 11, 2014
New EPA clean power standard highlights need for methane regulations
We at PennFuture were thrilled about the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) announcement last week of the proposed standard to limit carbon pollution from existing power plants. As we discussed, this rule is likely to have the most impact on the oldest, dirtiest coal plants because they can't compete with relatively newer coal plants, natural gas plants and other more competitive electric power resources.
But with more natural gas production on the way -- and the attendant methane leakage -- this Christian Science Monitor article raised an important question: Are we trading one climate killer (carbon dioxide) for another (methane)?
Next door, Ohio now also requires natural gas drillers to conduct quarterly inspections to find and fix leaks wherever they might occur.
Pennsylvania can, and should, be a national leader on methane. Other states have set the bar, and energy companies are meeting their tough new requirements. There’s no reason why it can’t happen here.
Andrew Sharp is Director of Outreach for PennFuture and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.
Since natural gas burns much cleaner than coal, producing about half as much carbon dioxide, making the switch from coal to gas can go a long way to achieving the rest of the remaining reductions, the administration seems to be thinking.
The big problem is that we don’t know what’s happening with methane emissions. Natural gas, which is essentially methane (CH4), may burn cleaner than coal, but what happens when it isn’t burned? As a greenhouse gas, methane emitted into the atmosphere is more than 20 times as potent as carbon dioxide over a 100-year period.
Natural gas production leaks methane along its entire supply chain – from drilling to storing, processing to distributing.
....
Natural gas may still have a climate benefit over coal. And even if it doesn’t right now, methane leakage could turn out to be a very fixable problem, as engineers figure out how to plug the leaks in the supply chain.As the author points out, fugitive methane emissions are something we can address. But we must act now. Methane leakage can be significantly and cost-effectively controlled with proper equipment and robust monitoring and repair. Colorado recently put in place the nation’s most comprehensive regulations to control air emissions from oil and gas operations, including the first direct state regulation of methane.
Next door, Ohio now also requires natural gas drillers to conduct quarterly inspections to find and fix leaks wherever they might occur.
Pennsylvania can, and should, be a national leader on methane. Other states have set the bar, and energy companies are meeting their tough new requirements. There’s no reason why it can’t happen here.
Andrew Sharp is Director of Outreach for PennFuture and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.
Labels:
carbon pollution,
coal,
EPA,
methane
Wednesday, April 30, 2014
As the wind blows
Good news for clean air: On Tuesday, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Transport Rule. The rule
requires that 28 states,
which contribute significantly to downwind non-attainment of National Ambient
Air Quality Standards (NAAQS), reduce their emissions in accordance with
economic feasibility, as determined by the EPA.
The decision is a strong statement in favor of clean air and human health and against unmitigated air pollution.
For decades, as outlined in the SCOTUSblog, the EPA has struggled to effectively implement the “good neighbor policy” first issued in 1977, and updated in 1990, which seeks to require states to manage their own pollution rather than passing it along to others.
The decision is a strong statement in favor of clean air and human health and against unmitigated air pollution.
For decades, as outlined in the SCOTUSblog, the EPA has struggled to effectively implement the “good neighbor policy” first issued in 1977, and updated in 1990, which seeks to require states to manage their own pollution rather than passing it along to others.
The crux of the problem is that air pollution doesn't abide
by political boundaries. Nor do airborne particles shift uniformly across borders.
Instead, prevailing winds flow from west to east in the U.S. For this reason, many eastern states contend with dangerous air pollution blown in from neighboring power plants, along with the particles and ozone generated from their own sources. Particle pollution and ozone are directly linked to increased rates of asthma and other cardiovascular health problems, in addition to climate change.
Because states can’t regulate sources outside of their boundaries, federal
level coordination is necessary in order to ensure that states that rely primarily on coal fired power plants (the dirtiest source of energy available) don't sit back and enjoy artificially cheap power by
transferring the health and clean-up costs to citizens and governments downwind.
Curious to know where Pennsylvania stands? The Tribune outlined our state's position back in 2013: Squarely in the middle.
Now that you've made it to here, reward yourself by enjoying this mesmerizing
wind map, which may or may not oblige me by illustrating the prevailing wind.
Valessa Souter-Kline is PennFuture's western Pennsylvania outreach coordinator and is based in Pittsburgh. She tweets at @ValessaSK.
Valessa Souter-Kline is PennFuture's western Pennsylvania outreach coordinator and is based in Pittsburgh. She tweets at @ValessaSK.
Wednesday, April 23, 2014
Victory for our health: Mercury emissions rule upheld
This month, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia upheld a key Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) rule to require coal and oil-fired utility power plants to reduce hazardous mercury and other toxic emissions. Industry and others opposed the rule on the grounds that the agency didn't consider the cost of the rule.
However, we in Pennsylvania know well the "cost" of mercury emissions: In 2009, EPA's Toxics Release Inventory placed Pennsylvania second nationally for mercury and mercury compound emissions from power plants. The cost to our health includes accumulations in humans and other organisms (fish we consume), risks to pregnant women, and risks to developing fetuses' brains. As many as one in six women of childbearing age have mercury in their blood above safe levels.
For more thoughts on the true cost: According to EPA, the proposed rule will prevent up to 11,000 premature deaths, 4,700 heart attacks, and 130,000 asthma attacks each year. That's a major health cost we've been shouldering nationally, and this rule makes a difference in addressing that number.
The EPA rule has survived various ill-intended attempts to weaken or eliminate it. In 2012, Senator Bob Casey voted down a Congressional attempt to derail the rule, standing with the major health, faith, and environmental organizations all working to protect the health of those most at risk: Babies and mothers. PennFuture has been working on this health issue on state and federal levels for more than a decade, including organizing testimony at EPA hearings and postcard campaigns (thank you, PennFuture supporters for your work on this!). This ruling is a victory for human health and against polluters but, unfortunately, it won't be the last word on the topic.
For more info and background, here's a brief round-up on the subject:
http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2014/04/16/3427336/court-air-toxics-ruling/
http://citizensvoice.com/opinion/states-should-end-appeals-comply-with-mercury-rule-1.1671417
http://www.natlawreview.com/article/dc-circuit-upholds-utility-mact-mercury-and-air-toxics-standard-rule-2-1-split
Kate Gibbons is northeast Pennsylvania outreach coordinator for PennFuture, based in Wilkes-Barre.
However, we in Pennsylvania know well the "cost" of mercury emissions: In 2009, EPA's Toxics Release Inventory placed Pennsylvania second nationally for mercury and mercury compound emissions from power plants. The cost to our health includes accumulations in humans and other organisms (fish we consume), risks to pregnant women, and risks to developing fetuses' brains. As many as one in six women of childbearing age have mercury in their blood above safe levels.
For more thoughts on the true cost: According to EPA, the proposed rule will prevent up to 11,000 premature deaths, 4,700 heart attacks, and 130,000 asthma attacks each year. That's a major health cost we've been shouldering nationally, and this rule makes a difference in addressing that number.
The EPA rule has survived various ill-intended attempts to weaken or eliminate it. In 2012, Senator Bob Casey voted down a Congressional attempt to derail the rule, standing with the major health, faith, and environmental organizations all working to protect the health of those most at risk: Babies and mothers. PennFuture has been working on this health issue on state and federal levels for more than a decade, including organizing testimony at EPA hearings and postcard campaigns (thank you, PennFuture supporters for your work on this!). This ruling is a victory for human health and against polluters but, unfortunately, it won't be the last word on the topic.
For more info and background, here's a brief round-up on the subject:
http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2014/04/16/3427336/court-air-toxics-ruling/
http://citizensvoice.com/opinion/states-should-end-appeals-comply-with-mercury-rule-1.1671417
http://www.natlawreview.com/article/dc-circuit-upholds-utility-mact-mercury-and-air-toxics-standard-rule-2-1-split
Kate Gibbons is northeast Pennsylvania outreach coordinator for PennFuture, based in Wilkes-Barre.
Wednesday, February 12, 2014
Toxic overload
As Allegheny County air quality monitors edged into the red, unhealthy zone on Tuesday, the Group Against Smog and Pollution (GASP) and members of a multi-group collaborative (including PennFuture) prepared for a press teleconference about air pollution. The teleconference was aimed at stopping Shenango's Neville Island Coke Works from continuing to dump toxic chemicals into the air. The facility is one of the region's biggest polluters and, thus far, efforts to hold the plant responsible for its illegal emissions have failed to protect the many residents who live in Ben Avon, Avalon, Bellevue, Emsworth and beyond.
Coke oven emissions
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) describes coke oven emissions as "among the most toxic of all air pollutants." The plants dump known carcinogens into the air along with unhealthy particle pollution that can lead to asthma and other severe health problems.
Enough is enough.
Shenango Coke Works violated air quality regulations on 330 of the last 432 days. On February 6, GASP issued Shenango a 60-day notice of intent to sue under the Clean Air Act.
The notice, along with the teleconference and press release issued today, make it clear that citizens and environmental organizations won't sit back while pollution prevention laws are broken and the air we breathe makes Allegheny County residents sick.
Valessa Souter-Kline is western Pennsylvania outreach coordinator for PennFuture, based in Pittsburgh.
![]() |
| Source: www.airnow.gov |
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) describes coke oven emissions as "among the most toxic of all air pollutants." The plants dump known carcinogens into the air along with unhealthy particle pollution that can lead to asthma and other severe health problems.
Enough is enough.
Shenango Coke Works violated air quality regulations on 330 of the last 432 days. On February 6, GASP issued Shenango a 60-day notice of intent to sue under the Clean Air Act.
The notice, along with the teleconference and press release issued today, make it clear that citizens and environmental organizations won't sit back while pollution prevention laws are broken and the air we breathe makes Allegheny County residents sick.
Valessa Souter-Kline is western Pennsylvania outreach coordinator for PennFuture, based in Pittsburgh.
Wednesday, February 5, 2014
ALCOSAN’s Wet Weather Plan is looking gray; does that leave room for green?
In 2012, PennFuture submitted comments encouraging the Allegheny County Sanitary Authority (ALCOSAN) to look for ways to green their Wet Weather Plan. The Plan is required by law, to outline a strategy to keep raw sewage out of our waterways.* The end goal is important. Our rivers provide our drinking water as well as places to fish, swim, boat and unwind. If our rivers aren't clean and healthy, we in Allegheny County lose out.
Reaching the Goal
How we reach the end goal has been the subject of a very public conversation over the past year. While ALCOSAN proposed gray infrastructure (pipes and tanks) to store more water, many groups, including PennFuture, are asking for green. Green infrastructure means capturing rain where it lands, before it enters the pipe system and, ideally, allowing it to soak into the ground or be taken up by plant roots. Unlike gray infrastructure, green doesn't just manage stormwater. Green infrastructure provides secondary benefits including limiting surface water erosion; creating habitat and passive recreational areas; shading urban spaces and reducing cooling costs (hard to appreciate in February but important nonetheless); offsetting climate change; cleaning our polluted air; and increasing property values.
If green is so great, why isn't it in the Wet Weather Plan?
Good question. The features that make green infrastructure great, including that it is on the surface, beautifying our neighborhoods while cleaning our water, are also what make it challenging to plan for. Green infrastructure must be integrated into 83 municipalities. Over the past year, understanding of the value of green infrastructure has increased dramatically throughout the county and the demand is now loud and clear, with leaders including Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald leading the way.
Let’s go green now
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) recently told ALCOSAN that the Wet Weather Plan won’t meet required water quality standards. With a new administration in Pittsburgh, the news may be a step forward rather than a setback. By asking ALCOSAN to revisit the plan, the EPA has left the door open for green infrastructure. Let’s take this opportunity to invest in clean water AND thriving communities by incorporating green infrastructure along with the gray.
*How does raw sewage wind up in the water, you ask?
As we build our homes, schools, offices roads and parking lots, we cover up soil and replace it with hard, impermeable surfaces. When it rains (or snows) all the water that hits those hard surfaces is sent straight into pipes instead of soaking into the ground. Once the pipes fill up, they are designed to overflow (so they don’t back up into your basement), and overflows dump not only rain and snow melt into our rivers but the sewage that flows in there, too. Gross, I know!
Valessa Souter-Kline is PennFuture's Western Pennsylvania Outreach Coordinator and is based in our Pittsburgh office.
![]() |
| Stormwater Bumpout Image credit: Philadelphia Water Department |
How we reach the end goal has been the subject of a very public conversation over the past year. While ALCOSAN proposed gray infrastructure (pipes and tanks) to store more water, many groups, including PennFuture, are asking for green. Green infrastructure means capturing rain where it lands, before it enters the pipe system and, ideally, allowing it to soak into the ground or be taken up by plant roots. Unlike gray infrastructure, green doesn't just manage stormwater. Green infrastructure provides secondary benefits including limiting surface water erosion; creating habitat and passive recreational areas; shading urban spaces and reducing cooling costs (hard to appreciate in February but important nonetheless); offsetting climate change; cleaning our polluted air; and increasing property values.
If green is so great, why isn't it in the Wet Weather Plan?
Good question. The features that make green infrastructure great, including that it is on the surface, beautifying our neighborhoods while cleaning our water, are also what make it challenging to plan for. Green infrastructure must be integrated into 83 municipalities. Over the past year, understanding of the value of green infrastructure has increased dramatically throughout the county and the demand is now loud and clear, with leaders including Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald leading the way.
Let’s go green now
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) recently told ALCOSAN that the Wet Weather Plan won’t meet required water quality standards. With a new administration in Pittsburgh, the news may be a step forward rather than a setback. By asking ALCOSAN to revisit the plan, the EPA has left the door open for green infrastructure. Let’s take this opportunity to invest in clean water AND thriving communities by incorporating green infrastructure along with the gray.
*How does raw sewage wind up in the water, you ask?
As we build our homes, schools, offices roads and parking lots, we cover up soil and replace it with hard, impermeable surfaces. When it rains (or snows) all the water that hits those hard surfaces is sent straight into pipes instead of soaking into the ground. Once the pipes fill up, they are designed to overflow (so they don’t back up into your basement), and overflows dump not only rain and snow melt into our rivers but the sewage that flows in there, too. Gross, I know!
Valessa Souter-Kline is PennFuture's Western Pennsylvania Outreach Coordinator and is based in our Pittsburgh office.
Wednesday, August 21, 2013
Corbett Is missing the boat, and we'll pay the price
Four former Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Administrators recently wrote an Op-Ed for the New York Times. If Governor Tom Corbett missed it, he needs to read it.
The subject was climate change. The four writers, William Ruckelshaus, Lee Thomas, William Reilly and Christine Todd Whitman, all headed the EPA under Republican presidents - Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan, George Bush, and George W. Bush, none of whom are light weights when it comes to conservative credentials. The Op-Ed makes several important points.
First, science does not support the claims of climate change deniers.
In the words of four Republican EPA Administrators:
The subject was climate change. The four writers, William Ruckelshaus, Lee Thomas, William Reilly and Christine Todd Whitman, all headed the EPA under Republican presidents - Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan, George Bush, and George W. Bush, none of whom are light weights when it comes to conservative credentials. The Op-Ed makes several important points.
First, science does not support the claims of climate change deniers.
"There is no longer any credible scientific debate about the basic facts: Our world continues to warm, with the last decade the hottest in modern records, and the deep ocean is warming faster than the earth’s atmosphere. Sea levels are rising. Arctic Sea ice is melting years faster than projected."Second, inaction on climate change has real costs, and we do not have time to wait.
"The costs of inaction are undeniable. The lines of scientific evidence grow only stronger and more numerous. And the window of time remaining to act is growing smaller: Delay could mean that warming becomes 'locked in.'"Third, protection of the environment and public health has always been a conservative value.
"As administrators of the E.P.A ... we held fast to common-sense conservative principles — protecting the health of the American people, working with the best technology available and trusting in the innovation of American business and in the market to find the best solutions for the least cost.
That approach helped us tackle major environmental challenges to our nation and the world: The pollution of our rivers, dramatized when the Cuyahoga River in Cleveland caught fire in 1969; the hole in the ozone layer; and the devastation wrought by acid rain."Fourth, conservatives should support President Obama's climate action plan to cut carbon emissions and invest in renewable resources.
"[P]resident Obama’s June climate action plan lays out achievable actions that would deliver real progress. He will use his executive powers to require reductions in the amount of carbon dioxide emitted by the nation’s power plants and spur increased investment in clean energy technology, which is inarguably the path we must follow to ensure a strong economy along with a livable climate."Finally, action on climate change will promote and not harm the economy.
"We can have both a strong economy and a livable climate. All parties know that we need both. The rest of the discussion is either detail, which we can resolve, or purposeful delay, which we should not tolerate.
[W]e must continue efforts to reduce the climate-altering pollutants that threaten our planet. The only uncertainty about our warming world is how bad the changes will get, and how soon. What is most clear is that there is no time to waste."Regrettably, the administration in Harrisburg doesn't get it when it comes to climate change. Governor Corbett dodges questions about whether he believes in global warming, and seemingly lacks serious concern about the consequences of not taking action on climate change. Instead of working to cut carbon emissions and invest in clean energy technology, the Governor rejects any new investments in renewable power, all the while offering billions of dollars in subsidies to coal and gas interests.
In the words of four Republican EPA Administrators:
"[W]e must continue efforts to reduce the climate-altering pollutants that threaten our planet. The only uncertainty about our warming world is how bad the changes will get, and how soon. What is most clear is that there is no time to waste."Should Governor Corbett continue to hide his head in the sand on climate change, Pennsylvanians will undoubtedly pay the price.





