PF Nav/HeadImage

PennFuture Facts :: brief, interesting looks at topical environmental issues PennFuture Facts :: brief, interesting looks at topical environmental issues
Showing posts with label streams. Show all posts
Showing posts with label streams. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 15, 2014

Legislative #FAIL: PA House and Senate side with special interests on two bad bills

Late Wednesday, the Pennsylvania legislature passed two bad bills that will harm the water and air of Pennsylvanians. Both HB 1565, the Subdivision Flooding Bill, and HB 2354, the Stall on Carbon Bill, kowtow to powerful special interests as they dismiss the need for clean air and water for all Pennsylvanians.

The Stall on Carbon Bill allows either chamber of the General Assembly to block and delay Pennsylvania from submitting its carbon rule compliance plan to the Environmental Protection Agency, raising the likelihood that Pennsylvania cedes control of its compliance program to the federal government. By creating three different entities (House, Senate and Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection) with authority over the compliance plan, negotiation efforts by affected businesses and stakeholders will be confounded. 

Further, the bill raises serious constitutional issues related to separation of powers. Rather than craft a feasible system to enhance legislative oversight of Pennsylvania’s carbon rule compliance, the bill is rife with stalling tactics as it creates layers of legal and procedural complications to the detriment of the people and businesses of the state. The Stall on Carbon Bill is an American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) initiative championed by Pennsylvania’s coal industry.

The Subdivision Flooding Bill ignores the twin issues of stormwater runoff and flooding as it caters to the state's powerful builders lobby. Pennsylvania citizens and communities have paid dearly in safety, life and property as a result of the consequences of flooding and stormwater. Part of the reason is the loss of riparian buffers in headwater and other streams that hold and slowly release rain and runoff. Passage of the bill now jeopardizes the riparian buffers along Exceptional Value and High Quality streams that not only reduce flooding and stormwater runoff, but markedly improve water quality, decrease pollution, protect drinking water, and improve habitat for fish and other wildlife.

Passage of these bills at the eleventh hour only serves to appease deep-pocketed interests and large campaign contributors. These bills can in no way be seen as helping to protect public health and safety. Rather, they do exactly the opposite. 

Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.

Wednesday, January 15, 2014

A tale of caution for a precious resource

Last week's major chemical spill into West Virginia's Elk River cut off water to 300,000 people. West Virginians could not drink, shower or wash clothes with their water.
Elkriver-def01_up-2_standard
West Virginia's Elk River
It is estimated that 1,200 gallons of a chemical, 4-methyl-cyclohexane-methanol or MCHM, was released from a tank. So little information is known about the chemical that state officials had to rely on the Centers for Disease Control for advice on whether and when the water would be safe for use. NPR reported that toxicologists were relying on their knowledge of the chemical makeup of the compound, and a single study that established lethal doses for rats, to make judgments about when it was safe to drink the water.

According to PennFuture friend Angie Rosser, executive director of the West Virginia Rivers Coalition, the state has yet to explain why the storage facility was allowed to sit on the river and so close to a water treatment plant that is the largest in the state. The facility had not been inspected by the state or federal government since 1991. The area where the spill occurred is known to West Virginians as "Chemical Valley."

The company responsible for the spill, Freedom Industries, reportedly supplies "environmental chemistries and services" to the coal industry. According to the American Association of Poison Control Centers, the chemical spilled is harmful if swallowed or inhaled. MCHM can cause eye and skin irritation, nausea, and vomiting. The EPA has no drinking water standard for MCHM.

Pennsylvanians should not consider themselves immune from such incidents. In 1988, a new storage tank at an Ashland Oil facility along the Monongahela River collapsed, pouring an estimated one million gallons of diesel oil into the river, and threatening drinking water for 750,000 Pittsburgh-area residents. As with the West Virginia spill, a dike around the tank failed to contain the spill.

As proposals are made to build up a petro-chemical industry on Pennsylvania's rivers that rivals Louisiana's Chemical Corridor, the West Virginia spill is a reminder that regardless of how plentiful our fresh water, it remains a precious and fragile resource in need of protection and conservation.

George Jugovic Jr. is chief counsel for PennFuture and is based in Pittsburgh.

Monday, September 9, 2013

VICTORY: In addition to saving a stream, UMCO set important legal precedent

This post is one in a month-long series speaking to 15 of PennFuture's significant victories. It was 15 years ago this September that we began our work to protect the environment and champion a clean energy economy.

Once upon a time (actually around 2004), there was a mine owner named Bob Murray who operated a longwall mine in Washington County, Pennsylvania known as the High Quality Mine. It was a shallow mine as far as longwall mining was concerned - as shallow as 210 feet below the ground surface - and, like many underground mines in Washington County, it crossed under a number of springs, seeps and streams.

Bob Murray - also part owner of
the Crandall Canyon Mine, where
six miners died in August 2007.
By the time PennFuture was asked by local citizens to get involved in the matter, we found that the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) had been permitting the mine in a very unusual way. Instead of issuing a single permit that comprehensively looked at the impacts of the entire mine, DEP was segmenting the project into individual authorizations that only looked at the environmental impacts from the next longwall panel. The streams that flowed over the mine were fed by shallow, perched groundwater zones. This was significant because this shallow source water could be permanently redirected away from the stream by mine subsidence fractures.

When PennFuture entered the scene, Murray's company, UMCO Energy, Inc., had completely eliminated every spring and seep above the portion of the mine that had been completed, including eradication of the flow in an unnamed tributary to Maple Creek known as the 5E stream, and DEP was proposing to allow UMCO to continue mining under, and no doubt eliminating, the next tributary that would be encountered, the 6E stream. 

For more than two years, PennFuture pursued litigation on behalf of local citizens that were concerned about the permanent impacts of the mine on local streams. Through a series of actions filed with the Environmental Hearing Board and an appeal to Commonwealth Court, PennFuture not only prevented DEP from continuing to permit the mine and the subsequent destruction of the springs, seeps and streams in the Maple Creek watershed, it also established important legal precedent on how DEP permits longwall mines.

In particular, the UMCO proceedings established that DEP had to comprehensively consider the effects of all anticipated mining on area hydrology, and could not make decisions based on an artificially narrow and segmented approach. In its supersedeas decision, Judge Labuskes of the Board chided the agency for its slanted approach, saying that it would not surprise anyone that the hydrologic impacts of a mine would appear insignificant if you focused only on small, isolated portions of the mine rather than looking holistically at the full impact of the entire operation.

The case represented a significant decision for Maple Creek and its tributaries, and had a lasting impact on how DEP permits mines in Pennsylvania.

PennFuture will celebrate 15 years of environmental victories on September 25. Please consider joining us!