PF Nav/HeadImage

PennFuture Facts :: brief, interesting looks at topical environmental issues PennFuture Facts :: brief, interesting looks at topical environmental issues
Showing posts with label shale. Show all posts
Showing posts with label shale. Show all posts

Monday, December 7, 2015

Shale & Public Health: A conversation that's not fading away

The League of Women Voters of PA presented its third annual Shale & Public Health Conference in Pittsburgh on November 18, and what's abundantly clear is that the nexus of natural gas drilling and public health in Pennsylvania is a subject of continued interest and debate.

A packed room at the University of Pittsburgh's University Club heard a succession of speakers weigh in on impacts to public health from fracking activity in the Marcellus Shale region ranging from compromised air quality to poor outcomes in newborns.

Dr. Bruce Pitt, department chair, University
of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health
Dr. Bruce Pitt, department chair of the University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health, is participating in leading research to better assess perinatal outcomes for mothers in natural gas drilling regions. He noted that there is a fetal basis for adult diseases that can be traced back to the environmental experiences of the mother. Dr. Pitt's current studies are focused on Washington, Butler and Westmoreland counties in southwestern PA -- a heavily-fracked region -- and are showing an increased incidence of babies that are small for gestational age as well as premature births. Dr. Pitt further noted that we need more studies over "an extended period of time" to better assess the public health impacts of natural gas development, and that a 30-year cycle of study makes sense to allow for a full life cycle of fracking plus longer-forming diseases such as certain cancers.

The Southwestern Pennsylvania Environmental Health Project's Dr. Jill Kriesky reiterated the need for a registry on the health impacts of fracking in PA. "We need a [fracking] health registry since researchers have determined that there are public health impacts from this activity," said Kriesky. "The goal is for Pennsylvania to have a robust health registry other states would want to replicate so we have this data across the country."

Dr. Brian Schwartz of Johns Hopkins University is the lead on the much-discussed Geisinger study of health impacts in the fracking regions of northeastern Pennsylvania (NEPA). The Geisinger Health System, which has a large presence in NEPA, has an abundance of well-tracked data, making it a good candidate for study. "By using Geisinger data, we're studying the data of people in [fracking] impacted counties," noted Schwartz, adding that the National Institutes of Health is funding three studies to date that are looking at environmental issues and associated health outcomes. One study's key takeaway: An association between fracking and pre-term birth that is 40 percent higher, "conservatively," in fracking regions. Schwartz's continuing research includes studying asthma exacerbation in drilling regions (the disease's latency is short, making it an ideal vehicle to assess fracking impacts) as well as the study of certain cancers including leukemia and tumors.

Dr. Bernard Goldstein, emeritus dean and
professor, Pitt Graduate School of Public Health
Dr. Bernard Goldstein, the emeritus dean and professor of the Pitt Graduate School of Public Health, touched down in Pittsburgh the night before the conference after spending the fall teaching in Cologne, Germany. Consequently, he honed in on the differences in how fracking is viewed in the U.S. and the EU. While European countries with large shale reserves are keen to drill, their public is largely opposed. That's in stark counterpoint to the U.S., where it's unlikely that we'll completely abandon fossil fuels, thereby making it ever clearer that we have to get drilling right for the sake of public health and the environment. Dr. Goldstein continued: "We have not had the oversight we need in Pennsylvania [on shale gas development]. No one on Gov. Corbett's Marcellus Shale Advisory Committee had a public health background."

It was clear after a full day of speakers and breakout sessions that the conversation in PA on shale gas drilling is fluid. However, much more has been learned, especially about the harmful air pollution related to fracking that is leading to negative health outcomes for Pennsylvanians, including our most vulnerable populations.

Consequently, we should continue to push for the strongest possible rules to address air pollution from natural gas drilling including methane emissions from both new and existing sources. Absent strong protections and strict enforcement, we will not be able to ensure good public health and a safe environment.

Elaine Labalme is strategic campaigns director for PennFuture and is based in Pittsburgh. She tweets @NewGirlInTown.


Monday, April 8, 2013

A primer on the Center for Sustainable Shale Development (CSSD)

PennFuture and four other environmental groups - the  Group against Smog and Pollution, Pennsylvania Environmental Council, Clean Air Task Force and Environmental Defense Fund - have endorsed a set of fifteen environmental protection standards developed with several large shale gas producers in the Marcellus region: Chevron, Shell, EQT and CONSOL. At the core of the nascent Center for Sustainable Shale Development (CSSD), these standards were the result of two years of collaboration that included research assistance from the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and ICF International, both world experts on oil and gas environmental risk management. The initial effort was funded by two foundations, the Heinz Endowments and William Penn Foundation, as well as participating gas companies.

The initial fifteen standards - eight concerning water and seven air  - are intended to be more stringent than current federal and state standards in the Appalachian Basin. Examples include:
  • zero discharge of wastewater to surface and ground waters until a safe treatment standard has been developed;
  • a 90 percent wastewater recycling requirement within two years;
  • eliminating the use of open pits at well pads within two years;
  • operators must characterize area geology, perform a risk assessment to protect against fluid migration, and ensure surface and ground water quality is not impacted;
  • use well casings and cement to prevent migration of fluids and contamination of ground water;
  • use of green completions to substantially eliminate flaring of well head gas by January 2014; and
  • compliance with tight air emission standards for all diesel engines used in drilling and any trucks servicing a well pad.

CSSD's members have committed to regularly review existing standards, and will develop additional standards to protect air, land and water.

PennFuture joined in developing and endorsing these standards because it is our mission to protect the environment, and we believe these standards will advance that mission. It is important that four of the major gas producers in Pennsylvania have agreed to meet these standards because it shows that tougher environmental standards for gas drilling in Pennsylvania are economically feasible.

These standards are not a substitute for improved federal and state laws, or for rigorous enforcement of existing laws. That is why PennFuture will continue to advocate for tough, common sense standards to protect our land, air and water - including no drilling in Pennsylvania's State Parks - and take action to enforce existing laws when the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) does not.

PennFuture understands that some environmental organizations categorically oppose the extraction of unconventional gas, in part on the theory that more gas leads to greater air pollution and climate change. Certainly, natural gas should not be the only way we produce power in the United States. However, while the data is still unclear on the benefits of natural gas over coal as far as climate change is concerned, there can be no doubt that gas offers a better alternative when it comes to acid mine drainage, mercury and sulfur emissions.

Coal, oil and gas still comprise about 82 percent of U.S. energy demand. PennFuture works hard to reduce that percentage by advocating for energy conservation and use of renewables. But so long as the nation relies on fossil fuels for electric power, it is our obligation to protect the environment while those non-renewable resources are being extracted.

These new standards could play an important role in minimizing the harm caused by continued reliance on fossil fuels.  That is why PennFuture participated in the process.