Submitting written comments on proposals
involving regulatory agencies' approval is one of the behind-the-scenes ways PennFuture
staff (our legal team as well as other staff) participates in
federal and state environmental issues. The proposed Atlantic Sunrise pipeline is
an example of a current case in which we submitted concerns that the Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) should consider.
Why
submit comments, you might ask -- and who reads them? By law, federal agencies
must consult the public in making rules and regulations. It's not just the
law -- it's good governance in a democracy. The process for involving the
American public in rulemaking has its origins in the New Deal of the 1930s,
when a large number of new programs and agencies -- including Social Security,
the Federal Housing Administration (FHA), the Federal Communications Commission
(FCC), and the National Labor Relations Board – were launched following the
Great Depression. Congress enacted a series of laws giving the public the means
to weigh in on the development
of rules that affect us, and requiring agencies to consider these submissions in the decisions and maintain them in a public record. For more on how that works (for policy wonks out there), the Congressional Research Service provides this detailed history.
PennFuture's written comments to FERC, submitted by staff attorney Mike Helbing, are now part of the public record on the Atlantic Sunrise pipeline,
which will cross 192 miles of Pennsylvania's lands and waterways from
Lancaster to Susquehanna counties. It is clear that this project will
create numerous environmental impacts across its route. We know that our
history as a Commonwealth has been marked by ill-conceived use and
misuse of our natural resources, leaving environmental devastation. This
pipeline project has major direct and indirect impacts that threaten water, air and land resources as well as public safety. To
prevent history from being repeated, it is important that each of these impacts be carefully considered before ground is broken for the new pipeline.
Among
the issues PennFuture raised are the potential for increased methane emissions,
additional forest fragmentation and subsequent decrease in wildlife habitat,
and water quality impacts. We emphasized to FERC the importance of performing a thorough cumulative impacts analysis
and considering the project’s indirect
effects as part of its Environmental Impacts Study (EIS).
So, what
happens next? The pipeline company will submit a formal application and FERC
will prepare the EIS, taking the public comments into consideration. Once
the EIS is complete, the public will again be given an opportunity to review
and comment on it before it is finalized.
(You can learn more about the process through FERC’s website.) Finally,
all written comments and public testimony submitted by the hundreds on this
pipeline are available at http://elibrary.ferc.gov/idmws/docket_search.asp
(Search for Docket Number: PF14-8) --
and are a reminder of the role we as citizens can play in protecting our
natural resources and public health.
Kate Gibbons is PennFuture's Northeastern Pennsylvania outreach coordinator.
Showing posts with label pipeline. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pipeline. Show all posts
Wednesday, September 3, 2014
Wednesday, May 1, 2013
Wet Gas, Pipelines, Fractionation and a Changing Landscape
The Dayton Daily News recently reported that Houston-based Enterprise Products Partners would begin expansion of the ATEX Express Pipeline in Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Indiana. These types of projects will continue to come online in an effort to push natural gas liquids (NGL) from Southwest Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia to the Gulf Coast and elsewhere, and it will be sure to change our landscape.
Most Pennsylvanians know NGL as "wet gas" - the liquids produced in association with methane. NGL production is growing by leaps and bounds in certain parts of the Marcellus and Utica shale plays. As industry analysts RBN Energy explain, NGL itself does not have much value until it undergoes fractionation - the process of separating NGL into its component parts - ethane, propane, butane, iso-butane, and methane (or pure natural gas).
Once LNG is broken down, the ethane component can be used as feedstock at an olefin or cracker facility to produce ethylene, a basic building block for making plastics. This is what Shell is considering for Beaver County. The other components can be shipped to various domestic and overseas markets, such as the growing Latin American market for propane.
If the NGL cannot be fractionated, production at the well head must stop - and that is not good for companies that invested millions of dollars to purchase gas reserves. For that reason there is a rush to rapidly ramp up fractionation capacity and construct pipelines to transport LNG and various components to market.
The Enterprise pipeline is being constructed to transport NGL to Texas. Sunoco/MarkWest are constructing the Mariner West pipeline to take NGL north to a fractionation complex in Sarnia, Ontario, which will eventually deliver products throughout Canada. The Mariner East Project will take NGL from Southwest Pennsylvania to Sunoco's processing facilities on the Delaware River, and from there products will ship overseas and to other markets.
In addition to pipelines, the major Midstream companies operating in Southwest PA (MarkWest, Dominion, Williams and Chesapeake) are constructing up to eleven fractionation facilities between Moundsville, WV and Houston, PA - less than 50 miles apart. At the same time, numerous expansion projects along the Gulf Coast are underway to increase fractionation and cracker capacity there.
These pipelines and fractionation facilities will enable NGL production from Marcellus and Utica shale to boom. According to Callie Mitchell, an RBN Energy analyst, NGL production in Southwest PA is poised to grow astronomically in the next five years - as shown on this graph - from 43 Mb/d (a meager 1.2% of US annual production) to an astounding 450 Mb/d by 2017.
Governor Corbett and others envision the processing of wet gas as a "second industrial revolution" that will "transform" all of Pennsylvania into a second Gulf Coast that doesn't just produce gas, but also processes it. In contrast, I recently heard an industry insider dismiss that vision as a "pipedream," explaining that it was much more convenient to enlarge existing facilities on the Gulf Coast, with their easy access to shipping ports and downstream markets, than to reconstruct Mont Belvieu, Texas along the Ohio River. Most likely it will be a blend - perhaps more a rowdy party than a revolution. We will see.
The Governor now does not expect to know whether Shell will build a cracker plant in Beaver County until sometime next year.
One thing is certain - wet gas will continue to change our landscape. This blog will continue to explore what those changes will mean for our communities and environment.
Most Pennsylvanians know NGL as "wet gas" - the liquids produced in association with methane. NGL production is growing by leaps and bounds in certain parts of the Marcellus and Utica shale plays. As industry analysts RBN Energy explain, NGL itself does not have much value until it undergoes fractionation - the process of separating NGL into its component parts - ethane, propane, butane, iso-butane, and methane (or pure natural gas).
Once LNG is broken down, the ethane component can be used as feedstock at an olefin or cracker facility to produce ethylene, a basic building block for making plastics. This is what Shell is considering for Beaver County. The other components can be shipped to various domestic and overseas markets, such as the growing Latin American market for propane.
If the NGL cannot be fractionated, production at the well head must stop - and that is not good for companies that invested millions of dollars to purchase gas reserves. For that reason there is a rush to rapidly ramp up fractionation capacity and construct pipelines to transport LNG and various components to market.
The Enterprise pipeline is being constructed to transport NGL to Texas. Sunoco/MarkWest are constructing the Mariner West pipeline to take NGL north to a fractionation complex in Sarnia, Ontario, which will eventually deliver products throughout Canada. The Mariner East Project will take NGL from Southwest Pennsylvania to Sunoco's processing facilities on the Delaware River, and from there products will ship overseas and to other markets.
In addition to pipelines, the major Midstream companies operating in Southwest PA (MarkWest, Dominion, Williams and Chesapeake) are constructing up to eleven fractionation facilities between Moundsville, WV and Houston, PA - less than 50 miles apart. At the same time, numerous expansion projects along the Gulf Coast are underway to increase fractionation and cracker capacity there.
These pipelines and fractionation facilities will enable NGL production from Marcellus and Utica shale to boom. According to Callie Mitchell, an RBN Energy analyst, NGL production in Southwest PA is poised to grow astronomically in the next five years - as shown on this graph - from 43 Mb/d (a meager 1.2% of US annual production) to an astounding 450 Mb/d by 2017.
Governor Corbett and others envision the processing of wet gas as a "second industrial revolution" that will "transform" all of Pennsylvania into a second Gulf Coast that doesn't just produce gas, but also processes it. In contrast, I recently heard an industry insider dismiss that vision as a "pipedream," explaining that it was much more convenient to enlarge existing facilities on the Gulf Coast, with their easy access to shipping ports and downstream markets, than to reconstruct Mont Belvieu, Texas along the Ohio River. Most likely it will be a blend - perhaps more a rowdy party than a revolution. We will see.
The Governor now does not expect to know whether Shell will build a cracker plant in Beaver County until sometime next year.
One thing is certain - wet gas will continue to change our landscape. This blog will continue to explore what those changes will mean for our communities and environment.
Labels:
Corbett,
cracker,
fractionation,
Marcellus,
natural gas,
pipeline,
wet gas