PF Nav/HeadImage

PennFuture Facts :: brief, interesting looks at topical environmental issues PennFuture Facts :: brief, interesting looks at topical environmental issues
Showing posts with label Governor Tom Corbett. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Governor Tom Corbett. Show all posts

Thursday, January 29, 2015

BREAKING NEWS: Gov. Tom Wolf reinstates moratorium on further gas leasing of public lands

Great news for Pennsylvania's state forests and state parks. 

In a ceremony at Benjamin Rush State Park in Philadelphia this morning, Governor Wolf reinstated a moratorium on further gas leasing of public lands. The executive order would supersede an executive order signed by former Gov. Tom Corbett last year that overturned a previous ban on further drilling of public lands.

We are pleased to see Gov. Wolf move quickly to protect our state parks and forests from natural gas drilling. These lands are held in the public trust as provided by Article 1, Section 27 of the Pennsylvania constitution, and are places where our families gather and play. The governor has wisely chosen to protect the people of Pennsylvania over the profits of drillers.

With the help of PennFuture members and thousands of Pennsylvanians across the state, we kept the pressure on Harrisburg -- and your voices were heard.

The citizens of the Commonwealth have long valued the special places that our award-winning state parks and state forest represent. Gov. Wolf's action today will help preserve those places as it promotes public health.


Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. 

Wednesday, October 22, 2014

VIDEO: "Methane Matters: PA Needs to Know"

You've got questions and we've got answers. What is methane? Why is it leaking from Pennsylvania's natural gas operations? Why is methane such a threat to climate change? Check out this whiteboard animation video for a helpful primer -- then share it with friends.  


Methane Matters: PA Needs to Know from PennFuture on Vimeo.

Wednesday, October 15, 2014

Scranton Times-Tribune ed board: Look to Colorado on methane rules

The chorus calling for Pennsylvania to address methane emissions from the natural gas sector continues to grow. Last week, the editorial board of the Lancaster Intelligencer-Journal said that stopping methane leakage should be a critical focus of the Wolf and Corbett campaigns -- and both candidates were asked about the issue in last week's final gubernatorial debate sponsored by the League of Women Voters.

This week, the Scranton Times-Tribune's editorial board weighed in and said Colorado should be a model for Pennsylvania:
...Colorado is the only major gas-drilling state to regulate against methane emissions. Its rules, implemented earlier this year, were crafted by a coalition of energy companies and environmental groups and should become a model for Pennsylvania. Several other gas-producing states, including Ohio, have begun to consider regulations based on the Colorado model.
The Colorado regulations require companies to find and repair methane leaks, processes for which technology already exists. Four of the biggest producers and processors in Colorado — Encana, Anadarko, Noble Energy and DCP Midstream Denver — worked on the new regulatory regime with the Environmental Defense Fund, Conservation Colorado, Earthjustice, Sierra Club, Natural Resources Defense Council, WildEarth Guardians and Earthworks Oil and Gas Accountability Project.
The companies say compliance will cost the industry about $20 million a year, but opponents of the new model say it could cost up to $100 million. Some of the cost will be offset because the companies will sell the methane they capture. According to Colorado government estimates, the new system will recover about 65,000 tons of methane a year that otherwise would have escaped. The same system also will capture another 90,000 tons of smog-causing volatile organic compounds, the state estimated.
For gas to fulfill its potential as a “bridge” fuel, methane emissions must be controlled. Pennsylvania should adopt the Colorado model.
Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.

Wednesday, October 8, 2014

The chorus grows: Methane rules needed in PA

The threat of methane emissions from natural gas drilling has been coming into clearer focus this year, and there is real momentum for action in Pennsylvania. This past Sunday, the Lancaster Intelligencer-Journal's editorial board called on the state's next chief executive to implement new methane rules:
"Pound for pound, methane’s impact on the climate is more than 20 times greater than that of carbon dioxide, the most prevalent atmosphere-warming gas.

At the federal level, the Obama administration has made methane reduction a key element of its climate change strategy, and new federal regulations will likely take hold within a couple of years. But Pennsylvania shouldn't wait.
States like Colorado, Wyoming and Ohio are now taking the initiative to work with natural gas producers to curb methane emissions, and it’s time for Pennsylvania to follow suit.
A Pittsburgh Tribune-Review report last week found the state’s aging natural gas distribution network, including some 10,000 miles of dangerously leaky pipes, sprang more than 31,000 leaks in 2013. Those leaks can pollute our air and leach into the water table.
The natural gas industry understandably wants to maximize profit, and it’s hard to focus on the long-term financial benefit associated with preventing methane loss when you’re staring at a substantial short-term outlay of capital to implement mitigation systems.
The best way for the gas industry to reduce the amount of natural gas it leaks and vents into the atmosphere is to upgrade the infrastructure that produces, transports and stores the gas, and that’s not going to happen without it being a requirement of doing business in Pennsylvania.
Pennsylvania needs the economic push of natural gas. But that push can't come at the expense of the environment in general and the release of increased amounts of methane gas into the air we breathe.
Balancing the two concerns should be a critical focus of both the Corbett and Wolf campaigns."
And the chorus continues to grow. Just this week, the New York Times weighed in with a call to address methane pollution, calling this a "moment  of truth" for the gas industry. 

Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

Fifteen senators press Obama for methane standards

"WASHINGTON -- Fifteen senators are pressing the Obama administration to regulate methane emissions from oil and gas production, arguing that addressing methane is a "key component" of curbing planet-warming emissions. 
"Ton for ton, methane causes at least 80 times more warming than carbon dioxide over a 20-year period," wrote the 13 Democratic senators and two Independents, led by Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), in a letter addressed to President Barack Obama on Friday. "Voluntary standards are not enough. Too many in the oil and gas sector have failed to adopt sound practices voluntarily, and the absence of uniform enforceable standards has allowed methane pollution to continue, wasting energy and threatening public health." 
The Environmental Protection Agency released five white papers in April looking at emissions from oil and gas operations. EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy said Friday in a meeting with reporters that the agency is now in the process of developing a strategy for addressing those emissions. That strategy, which the EPA plans to release some time this fall, "will look at what tools we have and what we think are most appropriate" for addressing the matter, McCarthy said. She did not specify whether the agency would recommend voluntary measures or new regulations."
The potential for federal methane rules could be a big step in the right direction. This strategy has the potential to deliver the federal regulatory oversight that is needed to complement much-needed state efforts and make sure that all of the oil and gas industry meets basic, common-sense standards to deploy readily available technologies. 

But federal rules don't replace the need for Pennsylvania to get its methane problem under control. As the fastest growing natural gas producer in the country -- and a state that emits nearly a full percent of the world's greenhouses gases -- Pennsylvania can't afford to wait. 

Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's director  of outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.

Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Corbett's former health secretary says state not addressing fracking health concerns

Last week, we brought you the news that Pennsylvania Department of Health employees were sent a list of fracking-related buzzwords as part of official guidance for how to handle complaints to the department -- and told not to personally return calls from people who used words on the list.

This weekend, Governor Corbett's former top health department official said the state wasn't doing nearly enough to study the health impacts of tracking. 

“The lack of any action speaks volumes," said Dr. Eli Avila. “Don't BS the public. Their health comes first."

Corbett's current health secretary, Michael Wolf, said he hasn't spoken directly to the governor about possible health impacts from the drilling boom, only to the governor's staff. 

PennFuture, along with the Sierra Club, Clean Air Council, PennEnvironment and Clean Water Action, put out a joint statement yesterday demanding an investigation:
"We are calling for a full independent and transparent investigation into the Pennsylvania Department of Health's response to drilling complaints. The legitimate questions of Pennsylvania citizens concerning their health or that of family members as a result of natural gas drilling activity cannot be discounted or dismissed outright. The fact that the department originally denied the existence of a “buzzwords” list, and the fact that Governor Corbett has refused to weigh in with a forceful response, leaves us no choice but to call for a full investigation. We are also asking the department to make available to the public all past and future health complaints, and to commit to addressing all future complaints in a timely manner." 
"This entire episode begs the question: Is the Corbett administration more concerned with protecting the natural gas industry than it is the health and welfare of Pennsylvania families and future generations? There should not be one set of rules for the gas industry and another set for everyone else. If there is any question that the actions of drillers are causing harm to our air, water and land as well as the health of our citizens, the governor and state agencies must address those concerns immediately. Governor Corbett needs to show leadership on this issue of great public concern, not delay and deny."
Stay tuned. This is a story we'll be following closely.  

Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's Director of Outreach and is based in Philadelphia. He tweets at @RexBainbridge.

Wednesday, April 23, 2014

Governor's plan for leasing on state lands brings questions but no answers.


Last week, I attended the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources' (DCNR) Natural Gas Advisory Committee meeting to get a first glimpse of the highly anticipated Marcellus Monitoring Report. The meeting was divided into two parts, with the second half devoted to the monitoring report and the first focusing on Governor Tom Corbett's proposal to allow further leasing of Pennsylvania’s state parks and state forests so long as there is no additional “surface disturbance.”

The governor’s proposal would require drilling of the newly leased lands to occur from adjacent private lands or from already leased state lands. Given these restrictions, representatives from the gas industry expressed serious concerns regarding the practicality and feasibility of the proposal. Essentially, the big question was: Is it really possible to not have additional surface disturbance?

Here’s why. Well pads are designed for a certain number of wells, and wells can’t be drilled like spokes in a wheel; rather, the direction of their laterals is often determined by geology. These constraints only raised more questions, e.g. can drillers request additional well pads if they’re allowed under the existing lease? Can drillers expand existing pads if that’s needed to make drilling feasible?

Industry representatives also said that some temporary disturbance will be needed, and this prompted multiple questions from committee members, including: What is temporary? How long is temporary? Does the disturbance have to be low impact? What is low impact? Would seismic testing be permitted?

All of these questions raised concerns over the value of these leases. Specifically, given the restrictions in the governor’s proposal and the limited access drillers would have, would this lack of competition devalue the leases?  

Unfortunately, none of these questions were answered, and you have to wonder: Just how well thought out was the governor’s proposal?

Jennifer Quinn is central Pennsylvania outreach coordinator for PennFuture and is based in Harrisburg. She tweets @QuinnJen1.



Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Say it ain't so: Corbett's budget calls for more gas leasing of public lands

Governor Tom Corbett delivered his annual budget address this week, along with his proposed FY 2014-15 budget.

The headline: The governor plans to lift a three-year-old moratorium on the further leasing of public lands for gas development to fill a budget gap. The budget factors in $75 million in drilling revenue to be accrued via further leasing of state park and forest lands for gas development.



The Corbett administration refers to the new drilling under public lands as "non-impact" drilling -- because no new well pads will be constructed, according to budget secretary Charles Zogby. It is unclear whether approved, but not yet built, well pads will fall under the moratorium. 

Of course, "non-impact drilling" is a fallacy -- even horizontal drilling without more surface disturbances creates more air pollution, more truck traffic, more water withdrawals, and more toxic waste water. And drilling just outside park or forest boundaries creates real risks for these public lands should spills or other accidents occur. 

Bottom line: Gov. Corbett is attempting to balance the state budget on the backs of our state parks and forest lands when he should be protecting these special places for this and future generations. 

Pennsylvania holds and manages its public lands in trust for all citizens of the Commonwealth, including generations yet to come. We have a responsibility to preserve and protect them, not sell them out for quick cash. 

Also of concern: The diversion of $117.5 million from the state's Oil and Gas Lease Fund (OGLF) as operational budget money for the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources (DCNR). The OGLF was originally designated for conservation, recreation and flood control programs in state parks and forests. 

Governor Corbett is not the first governor to raid the Oil and Gas Lease Fund -- but the practice is growing more alarming as our conservation and natural resource agencies are increasingly reliant on the rapid exploitation of the very resources they should be conserving. 


Governor's Enhance Penn's Woods initiative: Gov. Corbett announced the Enhance Penn's Woods initiative as part of his 2014-2015 budget proposal, allocating $45 million in new funding for parks and infrastructure. 

While moving to enhance public lands is always good news, the question remains as to when a new, and permanent, revenue stream will be put in place to protect Pennsylvania's crown jewels, our public lands. 

Our state parks are not only recreational and cultural assets, they are also an economic driver. For every dollar spent in state parks, thirteen dollars is returned to the economy of Pennsylvania. 
Despite this value, there has been a chronic under-investment in state park and forest resources -- because of this patchwork funding and lack of a consistent revenue stream. 

Corbett proposes DEP staff cut, increase in funding: The governor proposed a $10 million increase in general fund support for the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), from $129.8 million to $139.9 million. (For context, the DEP general fund budget was $245.6 million in 2002-2003.)**

Yet, he also proposed slashing 66 jobs at DEP — the agency tasked with policing the gas industry and protecting our air, land, and water. DEP has seen a 17 percent decrease in staffing over the past decade. 

It's hard to fathom how Pennsylvania is supposed to regulate an expanding industry with decreasing manpower. 

** Correction: In our original publication, we stated that that Governor Corbett proposed to increase the DEP’s 2014-15 funding to $136.7 million, while noting that the DEP’s total budget in 2002-2003 was more than $700 million. While true, this statement was confusing because $136.7 million is not the DEP’s proposed total 2014-2015 budget – only the share of the budget that would come from the general fund. The DEP’s total budget for 2014-2015 (including special fund monies and federal appropriations, as well as general fund monies) is proposed to be $689.3 million. By contrast, the DEP’s 2002-2003 budget was $728.3 million, or about $922 million in inflation-adjusted dollars.


Andrew Sharp is PennFuture's Director of Outreach and is based in our Philadelphia office.